Opinion | Readers critique The Post: Don’t erase women


Each week, The Put up runs a set of letters of readers’ grievances — mentioning grammatical errors, lacking protection and inconsistencies. These letters inform us what we did mistaken and, sometimes, provide reward. Right here, we current this week’s Free for All letters.

The Put up couldn’t discover a {photograph} of Rep. Liz Cheney (R-Wyo.) swearing in Matthew Pottinger and Sarah Matthews that included Matthews to accompany the July 23 columns by Margaret Sullivan [“Why Jan. 6 hearings are summer’s prime-time hit”] and Monica Hesse [“Liz Cheney understood her critical assignment”]? How on this planet, in these troubled, tough occasions for ladies and ladies’s rights, might editors have been so insensitive as to make use of an image that didn’t present Matthews and didn’t even point out her within the caption of the picture? Was there a feminine editor who seemed on the picture earlier than it was positioned?

On this listening to, Matthews’s testimony was extra simple and compelling than was Pottinger’s, and but The Put up selected to say solely him.

The Put up has made fairly a press release/omission with this one.

Marianne Anderson, Alexandria

Once more, the Sports activities part managed to disregard a girl. The blurb on the prime of the entrance web page of the July 23 part named three males who’re going into the D.C. Sports activities Corridor of Fame. However if you go to Web page D2, oh, look, there are the three males and Christy Winters Scott [“D.C. Sports Hall adds several to its ranks”]. I’m positive these two strains on the part entrance might have been rewritten to incorporate her.

The July 22 information article “Ukraine’s first lady says son now only wants to be soldier” irked me nearly as a lot as the unique interview on NBC Information. The interviewer requested Olena Zelenska how the struggle had affected her son. Zelenska spoke at size about how, earlier than the struggle, her son had quite a lot of pursuits, however now he solely desires to be a soldier. This dialogue turned The Put up’s headline.

The place was the Zelensky daughter throughout this change? Because the little one of a distinguished couple, the younger woman certainly has many hopes and aspirations of her personal, however in a situation acquainted to many ladies, she was rendered invisible by each The Put up and NBC Information. Not less than she appears to have been referred to briefly in an interview in Vogue alluded to on the finish of the article, however Vogue just isn’t precisely a serious information outlet.

Each The Put up and NBC Information have been remiss in leaving her out of the dialogue.

Clare Feinson, Washington

A deceptive miscarriage of journalism

The Put up conflated Israeli and Russian airstrikes in Syria with the deceptive July 23 information headline “Russian, Israeli airstrikes target 2 Syrian regions.” As even the article admitted, the Israeli airstrikes in query have been focused at hostile Iranian navy infrastructure in Syria. The referenced Russian airstrikes have been directed at civilians and aid employees in northwestern Syria, a part of a deliberate Russian technique to focus on civilian areas.

The article described Israel as Syria’s “sworn enemy” when, in truth, the other is true. Syria took half within the invasion of reborn Israel in 1948. From then till 1967, Syrian forces shelled Israeli farms and cities in vary of the Syrian Golan Heights. Syria participated within the Arab assault on Israel in 1967 and once more in 1973. Syria attacked Israeli forces trying to take away terrorists from southern Lebanon in 1982. Extra not too long ago, Syria has willingly hosted Iranian navy and paramilitary forces and installations which might be geared toward destroying Israel. The sworn enemy right here is Syria, and its longtime goal is Israel. These airstrikes have been separate occasions, with separate targets, contexts and historic backgrounds. They need to have been reported in two separate articles. Mashing them up collectively in a fashion that falsely impugned Israel was a miscarriage of journalism, or worse.

Daniel H. Trigoboff, Williamsville, N.Y.

The Three Percenters reside as much as their identify

The Put up has once more accused everybody who attended the Jan. 6, 2021, rally on the Mall of collaborating in an rebel. The July 17 front-page article on the Maryland GOP race for governor, “On Tuesday’s ballot: Trump’s vision vs. Hogan,” mentioned one of many candidates “helped constitution buses to the Jan. 6, 2021, rebel.”

In response to The Put up’s Nov. 7, 2021, special section on the occasions of Jan. 6, between 2,000 and a pair of,500 folks took half within the assault on the Capitol. Nevertheless, lots of of those didn’t attend the rally, going straight to the Capitol for his or her preplanned assault. On condition that tens of hundreds of individuals attended the rally on the Mall, just a few % have been concerned within the assault.

The opposite 38,000 or so participated in a peaceable rally, urging Congress to take motion underneath the Electoral Depend Act that the protesters (nonetheless mistakenly) believed to be justified. There may be nothing insurrectionary about that.

To accuse all of rebel makes no extra sense than accusing all those that took half in racial-justice protests in 2020 of being concerned within the riots that adopted.

Charles L. Orndorff, Amissville, Va.

I’m often impressed by the evenhandedness of The Put up’s reporting, however I used to be shocked and dismayed by the caption underneath the pictures of the 2 younger ladies accompanying the July 22 front-page article “Four teens navigate a suddenly post-Roe America.”

The primary lady was recognized as “a Christian” against abortion. There was no such description for the pro-choice younger lady. Was The Put up implying that she just isn’t Christian? She was, nonetheless, recognized as a member of a “highschool feminism membership.” Fairly a distinction.

Priscilla Ziegler, Arlington

How was it doable that “Abortion rights on the ballot in Kansas,” the July 26 front-page, above-the-fold, 50-column-inch article, with a full-page continuation and 5 images, in regards to the deliberately complicated language of an abortion poll initiative in Kansas, didn’t embrace the precise language because it appeared on the poll?

Terence Griffin, Rockville

Folks, not an ‘trade’

I used to be shocked that the phrase “abortion trade,” which Kathleen Parker utilized in her July 24 Sunday Opinion column, “The unbearable cruelty of no-exception abortion bans,” made it previous no matter evaluate course of The Put up makes use of for its opinion writers. There isn’t any such factor as an “abortion trade.” There are sufferers, and there are health-care suppliers. This challenge is inflammatory sufficient with out inventing a label for 2 teams of people that can’t be so summarily and inaccurately described.

Michael Goodman, Kensington

I learn the lengthy July 24 front-page article bemoaning the chip scarcity and the impact on the auto trade, “Chip shortage is upending the auto industry — even in Detroit.” Nowhere within the article was there a point out of what has prompted the chip scarcity. Rather less filler and extra explanations would have been welcome.

I’m fairly sure it has to do with stringent Chinese language coronavirus guidelines and our utter dependence on China for thus many issues, however an evidence would have been good. I count on extra from a front-page story.

Luisa Girlando, Annapolis

Right here’s a concept: They’re crackpots

The July 26 editorial “A glacial vote count” cited “Republican voting fraud conspiracy theorists.” I acknowledge that this time period is right here to remain, however I have to protest as soon as extra. Imprecise language deflects clear considering by affecting notion. This impact usually serves to reinforce the legitimacy of unworthy positions, notably in politics — the preeminent realm of the “spin.”

No case is extra egregious than the careless use of the phrase “conspiracy concept.” A concept has a revered which means: It’s the software by which scientists conceive, check and show or disprove believable phenomena. Elevating conspiracy fantasies to the authentic stage of theories does an ideal disservice, albeit subliminal, to analytical debate. Though now ubiquitous, the phrase could possibly be discarded no less than by the extra accountable venues of the written and broadcast media with a really minor modification of their type manuals.

George P. Hoskin, Burtonsville

There was a time when newspaper reporters have been pleased with their potential to make use of the English language to convey their tales to life. Are these days gone?

In only a cursory studying of the July 21 Put up, this gem popped up within the Metro part: “Waiting on results in a tight Md. rematch.”

Shall I appropriate this headline for the editors? Okay then, right here goes: “Ready for leads to a decent Md. rematch.”

If anybody insists on utilizing this improper instance, would possibly I respectfully ask that in addition they use the informal kind, a la the Rolling Stones’ “Ready on a Pal”?

That approach, readers would possibly have the ability to perceive that the writer is talking in slang, deliberately butchering the “Anguish Languish” (tip o’ the hat to Howard L. Chace).

I would come with the absurd use of the phrase “until” as a alternative for the contraction “ ’til.” However that should wait on one other day.

Stephen S. Ripley, Arlington

Congratulations to my fellow T.C. Williams Excessive Faculty (now Alexandria Metropolis Excessive Faculty) monitor crew alumnus Noah Lyles on attaining the American 200-meter dash file at this 12 months’s world championships, as famous within the July 22 Sports activities article “Lyles really lets it rip.” I hope by the point Lyles breaks the world file in that occasion, sportswriters can dig a bit deeper into the bag of folksy phrases than this text’s “Lyles crossed the end line, an acre between him and [the] American runners-up.”

I understand this was an try to be colourful within the grand custom of sports activities reporting, however an acre is all the time only a unit of space and bears no relation in any respect to linear distance — which is what is going to all the time separate Lyles from the pack. Subsequent time, strive a “light-year.”

Monitor protection is operating on empty

The July 24 Sports activities article “Dominance on the track, fan apathy off it” revealed the priority of athletes and supporters alike that the world monitor and discipline championships didn’t get enough public consideration. Clearly, this main occasion — second solely to the Olympics for monitor and discipline athletes — was not nicely promoted. The irony of this reality is that The Put up’s protection of the video games, which shouldn’t be formed by a company’s promotional actions, was minimal, contributing to this near-invisibility.

Apart from human curiosity tales similar to participation by Ukrainian athletes, I might discover no every day account of the accomplishments of those world-class athletes, together with those that established world or American information.

Vincent De Sanctis, Tilghman, Md.

Is irony misplaced on The Put up’s editors? After nearly ignoring the world monitor and discipline championships throughout your complete competitors, it printed the July 24 Sports activities article “Dominance on the monitor, fan apathy off it,” which reported, “World Athletics, the worldwide governing physique of monitor and discipline, views America as a market ‘not punching its weight.’ ” The article decried the seeming lack of publicity for a sport that, in accordance with the article, has “50 million leisure runners and a highschool system wherein extra children take part than another sport.”

Did the editors miss the file variety of U.S. medals, a world file and the world’s biggest feminine monitor athlete in historical past making, nicely, historical past, once more? One might solely guess for The Put up’s seeming lack of curiosity.

Since reporting on July 17 that “Trade of Soto may be on table,” The Put up has written:

Spotlight inevitably will remain squarely on Nationals’ young slugger,” July 19;

Trout? Mantle? Aaron? No comparison would be too outrageous for Soto.,” July 20;

Corbin deal could affect what Nats get for Soto,” July 21;

Trading Soto might be smart, but it also might be impossible,” July 22;

Soto trade or not, Nats will be busy at deadline,” July 23;

If Nats lose another star, fans might leave as well,” July 24;

Uncertainty with Soto lingers over Washington,” July 25;

Why do Nats let stars leave? Soto’s exit would revive the question.,” July 26.

Within the span of per week, The Put up ran no less than eight articles in regards to the doable commerce of Juan Soto. I’m hard-pressed to think about anybody, apart from world leaders, who has obtained a lot protection, however I can consider a lot extra who ought to — particularly those that don’t stand to make lots of of hundreds of thousands of {dollars} taking part in a sport. (And we marvel why a beer at Nationals Park is $10.)

It’s unfunny as a result of it’s true

I used to be dissatisfied by Suzie McKay’s July 23 Free for All letter, “Saying it all — or saying too much.” She was “appalled” by the “Doonesbury” strip of July 10 wherein a younger man between 18 and 21 was unable to buy alcohol however was in a position to buy an assault weapon. She thought the strip inappropriate due to latest mass killings and mentioned she was “saddened … this might be thought-about ‘humorous.’ ” However, for the previous 50-plus years, “Doonesbury” has all the time featured nationwide social and political subjects, has usually survived publications’ elimination makes an attempt due to readers’ overwhelming requests for reinstatement, and has even been positioned on some editorial pages.

“Doonesbury” is arguably crucial sketch ever produced.

Due to the legally convoluted however apparent system of congressional bribery we permit on this nation, the July 10 strip, sadly, is true. Relying on the state, it’s more durable to purchase a product (cigarettes) that may kill the client in 20 or 30 years than it’s to purchase a product (an assault weapon with high-capacity magazines) that may kill scores of different folks the following day. There may be nothing humorous about that.

Dave Bort, Keedysville, Md.

I agree with the thought of shooting-death field scores, as proposed in Dave Roberts’s July 23 Free for All letter, “Front-page news every day.” What will get measured will get performed.

I used to be nearly to go outdoors after I learn the July 25 Climate abstract, “Miserable heat and storm risks.” Boy, was I completely satisfied I didn’t go outdoors! Who in his proper thoughts would enterprise into the nice outdoor when The Put up warned us that warmth index values might close to the mid-100s? A warmth index close to 150 is an excessive amount of for me to deal with!

Source link

Related Posts

Next Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *